Showing posts with label channel management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label channel management. Show all posts

Friday, October 8, 2010

Metaphors to sell by

Over the last 18 months have you stopped and noticed how often the news' media brings up how one party or the other has availed itself of an advisor, a word-smithing advisor, who can teach that Party's spokespeople how to achieve its ends through language, through choosing "words that work."

Now stop for a second and think back to all those "lessons" you've been given over the years telling you what to say under what circumstances in order to break down any possible existing or lingering resistance when it comes to your trying to sell something to a potential, existing, or former customer. In other words, how to sell.

Were the words you were taught to use in order to be a better salesman "words that work"? And, did they work long term allowing you to achieve loyal, raving customers, or were they transactional wins that left you having to start from scratch each time you dealt with this buyer? Is there even the possibility that such a difference might exist?

Now stop and think about it for a minute. Have you stopped recently; listened to the language of your sales force and its leaders? How do they frame the exchange of value - product, services, information, etc - that takes place between your company and your intended customers?

(Another complementary issue to contemplate is the fact that the language used by sales, by marketing, your call center personnel, and the other functional areas that are customer-facing may not be the same).

The evidence likely will point to the use of rational argument and battle metaphors. If that is the case, does the language we use when talking about customers, prospects, and our slice of the pie undermine our long-term effectiveness and hurt our ability to form long-term, loyal relationships?

Is the language , the metaphors we use when we sell, unwittingly obscuring a self-reinforcing attitude and set of behaviors that is hurting our long term customer retention efforts?

Are we phrasing our marketing efforts as "campaigns" - miniature battles? When we "penetrate" an account are we blasting through the ramparts in order to take prisoners? and so on.

If we are seeking loyal relationships with our best, core customers, what language should we use, what metaphors should we sell by?

Cognitive scientists such as George Lakoff argue strongly that our metaphors are embodied. Does such embodiment insist that the net new creation of metaphors is highly unlikely, nearly impossible? Let us know your thoughts and let's explore this together.

Monday, March 1, 2010

CRM: it still is not a package or cloud Solution!

Effective CRM initiatives have yielded a gold-mine of profits, customer information, and competitive advantage. Yet, even a decade and 1/2 after CRM entered our business vocabulary, fewer companies succeed than fail. The artistry, the magic in successful CRM and Customer Experience Management comes from your company's ability to transform the data into relevant and valuable information, and then to again turn that information into actionable knowledge - again relevant, timely, and of value at each point across the customer corridor - a value that changes with each transaction or touch.

Sadly, many CRM & CEM initiatives have failed to achieve the "results" or the ROI that the sponsoring executives were told to expect. More alarming to me, however, is the fact that Customer Relationship and Customer Experience Management initiatives are believed to be technology plays: technology or package or cloud-computing solutions.

The failure to achieve ROI or to have "expectations" met could in fact be a result of failing to realize that CRM is not a package solution!

Loyalty-based, Customer Relationship Management is a strategy based on customer focus, on customer knowledge, and on delighting the customer. CRM is real-time, actionable, customer knowledge management. The best CRM approaches are holistic, involving all facets of your business and demonstrating accountability for results.
CRM becomes a guiding philosophy and framework for doing business.

Successful CRM practitioners anchor the initiative in their strategy, as well as in their mission, vision and values not in the package, or point-, solution they choose.

Thursday, November 12, 2009

Alice through the looking glass: words that work or not?

The last few pieces I've posted have dealt with finding "words that work". There can be no more important time to make sure you are using words that work than when speaking to a customer or prospect. Here's an interesting example of such an exchange: between "the customer" and "the company". A passage from Lewis Carroll's Alice Through the Looking-Glass serves as the example.

'Humpty-Dumpty said: "There's glory for you."

"I don't know what you mean by 'glory'," Alice said.

Humpty-Dumpty smiled contemptuously. "Of course you don't till I tell you. I meant, 'There's a nice knock-down argument for you!'"

But 'glory' doesn't mean 'a nice knock-down argument'," Alice objected.

"When I use a word," Humpty-Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, "it means just what I choose it to mean, neither more nor less."

"The question is," said Alice, "whether you can make words mean so many different things."

"The question is," said Humpty Dumpty, "which is to be Master - that's all."

Perhaps the example is a stretch, but each of us can remember an encounter similar I am sure.

Remember: It is not what you say that matters; it is what they hear. More importantly, if they have no idea what you mean by what you say, you can rest assured that what you hear will create a disconnect rather than a deeper connection with your customer.

Finding "Words that work" for your customer-facing roles

"English...tends to ambiguity and obscurity of expression in any but the most careful writing."

Robert Graves, the great English poet, mythographer and translator, wrote these words in his 1943 book, The Use and Abuse of the English Language. I can only imagine how Graves might react to the language of 21st century sales, marketing, and customer service efforts. If our written language is imperfect, what indeed can be said about our verbal skills?

For Customer Experience Management and CRM proponents, our message is this:

- there is a vital connection between your company and your customers that is forged at, and across, each touch point with them, as they move from suspect, to prospect, to trial user, to customer, and finally either to loyal customer advocate or to the position of terrorist, whose attitude threatens your reputation.

It is clear that we - each of us in those roles - must take more care, be more clear, be more precise, and more completely understandable as the company providing the service, products, solutions, and answers than our customers need be. Our front-line personnel can often feel besieged, if the customer is upset. Emotions can get in the way. In those "moments of truth", to borrow Percy Barneveld's phrase, when our frontline personnel are telling the product story, resolving an issue, or trying to sort through a complaint, the reputation and image of your company are put at risk.

Most of us understand this reality. Many of you have tried to communicate, train, and monitor your front-line people. Yet, all too often, it is the linguistic part of the interaction that causes the breakdown. I am not advocating scripting. I've never really liked the idea of any customer-facing representative having a script. I do advocate, however, guidance and planning: training, role-playing, on-going communications, and (perhaps even) a company-specific, conversational "dictionary" as actionable tools that each front-line, customer-facing individual can absorb and personalize.

In today's economy, our customers are looking for openness, resolution, and consistency. While words alone will not save or protect your reputation, words alone can sink your Customer Experience Management Efforts.

Sunday, November 1, 2009

The Integrated model - the essence of best practices CRM

The Integrated Model is a Gold Mine: it’s the essence of successful CRM.

In business-to-business marketing, the integrated direct marketing model is a gold mine for the marketing group that wants to build sustainable relationships with the right customers. The Integrated Direct model is the foundation of best practices Customer Relationship Management and Customer Experience Management. The economics of the Integrated Direct model come from two primary facts:

1. Marketers have come to realize that they cannot afford to invest in all customers and prospects equally. In fact, acquisition efforts should be segregated out from cultivation, retention, and “win-back” efforts. Integrated Direct Marketing – that is the integration of your “market coverage efforts (sales, marketing and service) - allows us to do that. This delivers the promise of CRM.

2. More expensive contact types, such as face-to-face or special events, can be leveraged with tremendous effectiveness by lower contact types, such as the Internet, social media, E-mail, print, snail-mail, and phone.

Here’s what the integrated direct marketing process can do for you:

1. Reduce the expense to revenue ratio by at least 15%

2. Increase the number and frequency of value-based contacts to the right prospect or customer

3. Increase the perceived service level at the point of contact

4. Increase product penetration

5. Increase customer loyalty

Additionally, in support of particular product lines, Integrated Direct Marketing ensures:

1. Faster Introduction

2. Higher amplitude of sales

3. Segmented and sustained market position

4. More control when migrating customers to newer models, products and services.

Quoting Bob Stone, long the venerable guru of American direct marketing, a definition of direct marketing must include three phrases: “interactive system,” “using one or more contact media,” and as must all direct marketing “effect a measurable response or transaction.”

Integrated Direct Marketing is not direct mail; it is not telemarketing; it is not transaction focused. The integrated direct marketing model is data-based and loyalty focused. Integrated Direct Marketing is highly targeted marketing that uses an integrated, organized, planned system of contacts by which we make offers to individuals using a variety of media. This system of building sustainable loyalty with our customers and prospects creates an on-going civil dialogue. It is accomplished by integrating communication across all contact media - print, the Internet, E-mail, mail, phone, field events and face-to-face visits from the field force. It’s defining characteristic is the delivery of relevant value. The value is defined for us by our customers and prospects. It provides for the delivery of relevant value-based information at the right time, in the desired delivery system, to the right individual that ensures interdependent relationships built over time.

This “Market Coverage” model makes use of the marketing database as the repository of corporate memory, storing the results of all interactions with customers and prospects.

In addition to simple facts such as demographics and product usage, today’s sophisticated marketers are building database systems that capture the complexity of buyers’ needs and purchasing behavior along with relevant complaint and/or satisfaction issues. The information then is available for product design groups, marketing, sales, research and other corporate functions. The database becomes the springboard for the organization’s need to be responsive, flexible, and dedicated to learning. Through the technology of our database, we are able to store response data by individual contact within an account. Moreover, we are able to measure our effectiveness relative to cost and to results. The measurability tracks profits, investments, expenses, account penetration (or, “share of wallet”), problems, issues, complaints and satisfaction.

Integrated Direct Marketing is a systematic method of getting close to our customers. Using this tool we can integrate our channel contacts and media efforts through a common database, which is focused on our target universe. Through testing we can validate results and expand our program and processes with great certainty.

The marketing database is mind of the IDM organization. It is serviced by a proactive outbound call center (or telemarketing unit), which becomes both a listening post to customers and the dealer channel as well as a way to leverage the field organization in building relationships and selling products. In the Integrated model the marketing database is shared with the field organization, your channel partners, and all internal departments.

The essence of a successful Integrated process is the ability to capture, centrally, information about our customers and prospects at all points of contact – and then to transform that information in actionable knowledge that is shared across and between those functional areas inside your firm that touch the customer or your channel partners. The key to success then is how well the marketer can segment within a given target audience. It is critical in the B2B arena to segment on similar sets of unfulfilled needs and purchasing behavior. This allows us to understand our customers’ need and how they buy and then to market our products and services to these identified niches.

Once the segments have been identified (keeping in mind that the entire target universe may emerge as one large segment), the next step to take is to grade accounts within segments to ensure that the investment made is the least amount of money to strengthen the relationship with the particular account.

The grading model is a valuation model. In the Business-to-Business world, the grading model no longer should be the simplistic A-B-C model. Instead, it should allow enough granularity to understand the profitability and penetration potential of each cohort or segment. I suggest 5 grades, although in certain cases, I believe 7 to be the optimal number of grades.

Grading (or, “valuation”) is the economic modeling of the Integrated Direct effort based upon an investment decision, which takes into, account the historical (actual) revenue and potential revenue from a particular segment of accounts. In other words, grading serves the marketer as an economic and analytical tool, which requires that we invest in the major segments we have created proportional to their economic history and potential.

Integrated direct marketing works both as a stealth defensive weapon, as well as a highly leverageable marketing tool. The competitive advantage it affords the skilled executioner is proprietary and affords increasing , not decreasing, economic returns. The fundamental concepts we use in loyalty-focused customer relationship management include:

1. Market to individuals … not to corporations

2. Address the unique set of needs of that buyer group (or application)

3. Individuals are clustered (i.e., segmented) around common sets of needs which define a market niche

4. All contacts with an individual, whether a customer or a prospect, must be of value as defined by them

5. The technology we use is transparent

6. Planning is critical

7. Testing is mandatory

8. Integration is the process used to ensure that the higher cost contacts are leveraged

9. Properly executed the integrated model creates a continuous improvement process that profitably drives business strategy by creating a sustainable atmosphere of cooperation and coordination across, and between, your company’s various functional areas.

10. The investment made is proportional to the level of commitment to us, to the expected return from this customer.

Saturday, October 31, 2009

A Few Thoughts on Customer Equity: the 20-200 Rule

The value of our business is the sum of the value of all our customer relationships

The value of your company is equal to the sum of all the revenue from all of your customers. Not exactly the textbook definition. Your CFO, without much grumbling, will allow it, however. Most of us are aware of Paretto’s Law, which would suggest that 80% of your profits come from 20% of your customers. A more startling rule is what Kaplan and Cooper call “20/200 Rule.” 20% of our customers return 200% of our profits. While you recover from the shock this statement presents – and, it is verifiable! – it is more important that we realize that there are proven fact-based approaches that lay down a roadmap that allows you to optimize your customers and mitigate the rules.

Like your other assets managed in your portfolio, your customers can be viewed as a portfolio of assets, which you can manage proactively. Successful management of your customer portfolio brings a serie s of cascading benefits to your firm. The primary benefits are your ability to maximize shareholder and stakeholder value; and your ability to optimize your “market coverage strategy.” The latter benefit is vital, since virtually every organization has limited resources. So it is critically important to invest those limited resource in direct proportion to the return we expect to receive from our investment in our primary assets - our customers.


it IS what you hear

Saturday note:

It IS what you hear. I'm not trying to beat a dead horse or plug someone's book, but this simple concept, one we all forget, truly is a lesson to be held close each day. We see examples of how language "works" in our daily public lives . Just consider the raucous behavior and emotional manipulation connected with such publicly debated topics as Health Care Reform; sending more troops to (or, the withdrawal of all troops from) Afghanistan; or the effect that cap and trade legislation will have on farming or our everyday lives. Language works in our lives: it gets things done; it produces results; it exerts an influence.
Whether it is my awkward attempt to talk to my 13 year old daughter about boys or acne or ?; or your time with a counterman at the dealership; or, your conversation with your spouse, remember this simple fact: it's not what you say it's what they hear.

Put yourself in their shoes. Seek first to understand. Stop and think. Be civil, respectful, and honest. Be open. Use language designed to build conversations and relationships.
Or, put this advice into your own words and add your own "rule".
What do you want your customers to hear? Given who they are, however, how do they hear, and translate, the words that you say?

Try this exercise in a "safe environment" (say with your "bride"). Ask your listener to "play back" to you what they heard. Were you understood? What affect did your words have?

Finding words that work, however, isn't the entire story. Listening, asking for clarificaton, seeking to understand: these are additional, critical elements of conversation. Conversation is what we want between ourselves and those who matter in our daily lives, as well as between ourselves and our customers.

For those of us deeply concerned about the customer experience, loyalty and customer relationship management, distracted by the pressures of business or life, we often can overlook how language shapes our results and the relationships we have with our listeners, our customers, friends, family.

If you want to analyze the underlying issues, go ahead. It could be the result of the Fall of the Tower of Babel or the speed of change in our world or careless use of "the Mother tongue". Let me know what you think. Thanks.

Sunday, October 25, 2009

it's what people hear

"Nostalgia", that longing for something out of the past. I keep thinking that with the speed of change and the increased complexity of technology and life, we have given up more than we realize. This can be true especially in our selling efforts and our relationship management initiatives.
When I look to where the world has sped these last 10 years, I long for a return. It could be my age. It could be what my advisor was trying to reveal when we read Ibsen's, "The Master-Builder" in grad school. Whatever the cause, I often wonder what we may have lost on the human side of our CRM efforts, given the speed of our world and the increasing complexity of our business models.
Needless to say, much of today's CRM technology is "mind-blowing" and "awesome." The systems we have today really are amazing. The depth of data we now can plumb astounds me, especially when I stop to compare what could be recorded and excavated (data-wise) a brief 20 years ago. As the kids would say, "OMG!".
But as I look at what CRM has done for our relationships with clients, prospects, the various constituents, I wonder if in our race to keep up if we haven't lost the essence of building loyalty with our customers. Consider the driving metrics for our sales, service and marketing contacts with our customers. I wonder if we haven't lost something, perhaps a certain "civility" in customer interactions. Is one way back, a constructive look in the rear-view mirror, simply to ask ourselves: How well do we ascribe to Stephen Covey's adage, "Seek First to Understand".
Or, maybe it is to think hard on Dr. Frank Lunt's words: "it's not what you say; it's what people hear." How well do we incorporate that simple advice into our daily customer interactions?

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

The Story of Babel.

All too often we, myself included, fail to realize the power of language in our daily personal interactions. Seemingly, if we stop to think about it at all, we tend to reserve a different style for certain situations versus others. The motives are varied: perhaps we believe that certain occasions, settings, circumstances require more conscious, formal and deliberate language, while others don’t need the precision or effort or . True enough I suppose.

Yet if you stop to listen to conversations, even our own, often words no longer mean what they once did: denotations, connotations, and the satellite of associated images no longer are as rich nor as nuanced. The end-game for casual substitution of one word for another with completely different sense would be a re-enactment of the myth of Babel.

With the fall of Babel, god left confusion: confusion that carries over in our marketing, sales and service language and CRM efforts. In the words of Willis Barnstone , “…God dispersed the word, gave us tongues and the solitude of difference, and also the impossible but pleasurable duty to repair our separation.” Translation necessarily must be a key component of our relationships and conversations. Translation is an important tool with which we can rebuild a new tower of Babel. Barnstone believes “it is an impossible task”; and, I believe it is one that clearly haunts our customer relationship efforts.

The challenge is when one word is substituted for another or mistranslated in the mind of either the speaker or listener. The slippery slope here would results with words in casual conversation having lost their precision; they no longer would retain the power of their meaning; and, eventually one word could be substituted for any other with impunity. The crime of being careless and imprecise eventually could bring about the demise of language. In all words would become the same.

Communication, as Lakoff & Johnson point out[1], “is based upon the same conceptual system that we use in thinking and acting.” When trying to build a loyalty relationship with your targeted and best, core customers, what metaphors does your organization use in its conversations with others: customer, business partners, suppliers, employees, investors, etc.? Two metaphorically structured concepts to think about are:

ARGUMENT IS WAR (think about that next time your group talks about its “campaign”).

Or,

THEORIES (AND ARGUMENTS) ARE BUILDINGS

Such mental frameworks do color our efforts to build customer relationship management and loyalty. There are a myriad of other examples about how language shapes our reality and relationship, such as: “orientational metaphors” such the special concepts “virtue is up; depravity is down” or Rational is up; Emotional is down”

In truth however, language is one of our most powerful tool in building relationships. We live according to the metaphors of our daily exchanges. The simple fact is “our ordinary conceptual system, in terms of which we both think and act, is fundamentally metaphorical in nature.”[2] Are we overlooking the power and value of crafting consciously the metaphors that shape our attitudes, demeanor and behavior? Our assumption is that looking at these questions squarely in the face might do more for our relationship and loyalty efforts than we previously have given credit.



[1] Cf. Metaphors We Live By, Lakoff & Johnson.

[2] Ibid.

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Reputation and Brand Image: using Voice of the Customer in your CRM

"Risk" is all over the news. In business Risk and Crisis Management are critical skills. Process-wise, nowhere in your business model is more suited to support risk and crisis management than "voice of the customer work." In today's world, when often the first thing people do is "to google" a subject, what does the world see about you? when the subject of that google search is The Company, what first impression does the web present; and, what problems are made evident that call into a "shadowy realm" either your Brand or your Reputation? Actually, there is, in all likelihood, a wealth of opportunity in that evidence. Evidence to be mined and tested and acted upon in your customer relationship management communications efforts.

We believe that the best CRM initiatives help to monitor in near-real-time that treasure of opportunity and use their customer insight work to connect back to the marketplace so as to manage the language of the marketplace and ensure that the company's values align with their targeted audience and customers to demonstrate evidence.

Companies must use their customer insight and "voice of the customer"and other market research activities as a vital, living, actionable and connected part of their CRM initiatives. In today's world, "the winners" will use their CRM projects to ensure that "voice of the customer" work is fed back into the knowledge management and activities of day to day business. These same companies will go the extra mile to ensure that their corporate values are aligned with the values of their key stakeholders. These companies will be able to align the softer elements of business: values - culture - brand- reputation- and customer experience. Coordination and cooperation across all functional areas will grow more critical.

For more than one pundit has concluded that "companies that do the best aligning their corporate values with key stakeholder values will rule the marketplace."

Monday, September 21, 2009

social media on the farm

How is your company using "social media'? How are your dealers, distributors and grower/producer end-users making use of it? Do you have your Facebook page, your bloggers writing, twitter-followers tweeting? How effectively has your initial forray been?
While, ownership and use of those tools would seem to mean that there is a clearly defined & articulated communications and CRM strategy, intention and purpose, the situation is eirily similar to the introduction and initial use of integrated, data-based, direct marketing and sales in the mid-90's.
I remember asking a client why they were building a marketing database: it was late '94, early '95. His honest answer: "we're not really sure what we will do with it - but everyone else is, so..."
Where does your company stand in adapting "social media"?
Clearly no one can deny its power. Most pundits will also insist that the customer insight must be incorporated into the feedback, learning, crm and customer experience management initiatives that already are in place. They also point out risk: for some, "social media" represents a reincarnation for them of "the wild, wild west."

Thursday, September 17, 2009

12 keys to succesful CRM and database efforts

A number of years ago, I wrote several pieces on what's needed to ensure that database marketing has a solid foundation. I wanted to re-publish this list because I think the principles are as sound today as ever.


1. Understand that successful database marketing is not a technology issue.

2. Draw a picture or process diagram of how the marketing database needs to work.

3. Focus on any output that will be used outside of your direct control.

4. Develop an effective customer contact plan.

5. Do not equate multi-channel, integrated, direct marketing with either direct mail, nor with telemarketing or your social media efforts.

6. Build the database manually first, before you automate it. The history of database marketing and CRM efforts is replete with stories of the best marketers actually using card files before they automated the functions. Strategy, process, metrics and execution are more important than the software.

7. Collect only data that will absolutely be used in the next 12 months.

8. Be rigid, not flexible. Your potential users will come up with many wonderful ideas. Hold firm as you start.

9. Use a simple proven solution: Software as a service (aka, "cloud computing solutions"), for example, may be an ideal vehicle.

10. Centralize all data entry, and validate outside input files.

11. Build and refresh your database on-line with information from your Customer Management Center, your social media channels and customer insight work.

12. Build a prototype -- not a pilot. Leverage the power of naming, in other words. The value is in the learning from this forray into building your database; don't let what you call it give any internal opponents the fuel to jeapordize the outcome.

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

An attempt to define "loyalty" - B2B world

Don’t be misled in thinking of loyalty as a collection of warm fuzziness and good feelings. Neither is it a synonym for customer satisfaction, nor for frequency of purchase transactions (although these are often associated with it). In the business context, "loyalty" measures specific behavioral elements over an extended period of time to assess the quality and durability of the relationship. Examples of these would be willingness to refer others and willingness to purchase again.
Today’s successful marketers must uncover what drives their customers to be loyal to them, and use that information to help increase their loyalty levels to build long-term relationships. These loyalty factors also play a role in whom you target as prospective customers.
The phrase, "you can’t be all things to all people" has never been more true than in today’s business-to-business marketing environment. In fact, those who try are rarely able to provide superior service to anyone. Consider what happened to IBM. As the company continued to proclaim the universality of its marketplace, millions of dollars of replacement part and add-on business went elsewhere. Might not a more focused strategy have enabled Big Blue to retain customer loyalty over the full life cycle of its equipment?
As we enter a new millennium, the single most important set of decisions any business-to-business enterprise can make are those involving selection — both of the products and services you will provide, and of the customers for whom you will provide them. In fact, recent research holds that it is a costly mistake — a diminishing of your resources and skills — to try to retain each and every customer. Contrary to the traditional wisdom of acquiring as many customers as possible, a critical skill we need to learn is how to identify and disengage with customers who are not profitable to serve. Let your competitors have them.

Targeting the right customer in the first place is the first half of the loyalty equation. Some customers are inherently price-driven — constantly on the prowl for a better deal, and ready to drop a supplier at a moment’s notice should someone else shave margins a little more. No matter how hard you try to please these customers, they will never be loyal to any supplier, no matter what value they receive, and are therefore worth very little in the long run in terms of profitability.
Other customers, however, inherently understand the high value of dependable, lasting relationships with key suppliers. Purchases are not random events for these customers, they are planned through long-term partnering, and as such are immune to momentary price advantages. It is these groups that are worth your ardent pursuit.

Selectivity, then, by this definition, requires that you use segmentation to align your core competencies with your customers and prospects. Your "bundle of skills and technologies" must match up to the cluster of accounts already grouped by needs and buying behavior in a way that makes economic sense. It demands that we keep our focus on long-term loyalty between the company and its customers, rather than frequency of one-time transactions. It advocates a "marriage" to a series of one-night stands.
That’s not a strategy that comes easily to people brought up in the older school of marketing, which counts volume of sales transactions in isolation, and measures gross market share, rather than analyzing the lifetime value (versus cost) of each customer. And it can seem especially threatening to short-term thinkers, pressured by the demands of the next quarterly report to stockholders.
Nevertheless, segmentation-enhanced selectivity is essential to a long-term view which places value creation as the fulcrum for ongoing success — especially in a world of parity products, right-sizing and/or consolidation, and easy duplication of product and service offerings.

What characteristics, identifiable from a distance, let you flag potentially loyal customers? That will vary, of course, depending on the profile of your business — your core competencies, goals and service philosophies. But the likelihood is great that many of them will look a lot like the firms who are currently your most valued customers.
The planned process begins with defining your business design: What products and service values are you set up to deliver efficiently and effectively? Within the broad universe of potential customers, which are the most logical targets for this set of capabilities?
Next, you can define the word "customer" to incorporate a quantifiable concept of profitability. In this context, a "customer" is a company that does X $ in volume with you, which includes Y number of different products, within Z time duration.
The next two steps are segmentation and grading. The two are entirely different processes which together create a very powerful economic model for customer selection, the purpose being to invest an appropriate amount of resources relative to profit potential.

Needs-based segmentation is the clustering of customers (and later, prospects) according to common sets of needs and purchasing behaviors as they relate to your organization’s external service values. Define the four to six reasons that most customers buy from you (which typically account for 80 percent of all decisions to purchase from your company). You then list the external service values which are most important to each customer. With this input, your marketing database can divide your customer list into one or more segments, each consisting of a group of customers who share a common set of needs and way of doing business.
Ideally, grading is done only within a segment; it’s the realization of economic value within that segment. It’s also a means of estimating the revenue available from that segment, and of understanding its unique needs, so you can talk to them as a group, via the lowest contact medium within the grade. There is, however, significant value in grading your entire customer file and investing in them proportionate to their level of commitment to you and potential revenue.
Finally, you need to analyze the lifetime value (LTV) to you of customers in each of these segments of your market. Within this, understand that LTV has more to do with how you treat your customers after you’ve acquired them than with the method of acquisition. Given what it costs you to acquire, supply and service this customer, the anticipated length of time you’ll retain its loyalty, the revenue that this will generate, and how much profit will it bring to you over the next X years (expressed in Net Present Value terms)?

With this information in hand, you can identify the types of customers who currently provide you with the lion’s share of your profits — and, by extrapolation, which characteristics you should look for in acquisition targets to achieve maximum profitability. This will then allow you to make intelligent decisions about resource allocation to acquire and nurture more of this kind of business.
A loyalty focus suggests that customer selectivity should be a matter of building up, rather than cutting back. Start with your best, most loyal customers (in terms of dollar volume, relative to wallet share; variety of product offerings purchased; and number of purchasers with whom you deal at the account). Fence these off and concentrate on understanding their needs and what constitutes value for them. You are now well-positioned to focus on them, opening a dialogue, and creating a "learning relationship" in which there is both an economic and an emotional benefit.

Database marketing provides the tools to find these answers. Marketing databases are designed to help you understand as much as possible about your customers, so you can build sustainable, mutually profitable relationships with them. Such databases are also the repository for "institutional memory," recording all contact and transaction information as it occurs. This allows account histories and resulting insights to be built on and shared throughout your company, far into the future. Compare this to the proprietary, fragmented possessions of many diverse individuals. When individuals depart, so does the customer information they hold.

The other half of the loyalty equation, of course, depends on what you do to earn it. Customer loyalty is most often a response to perceived value received. What creates that perception can vary from one group of customers to another — and indeed, from one individual firm to another. Until you know how various types of customers define that "value," understanding both their priorities and their concerns, you’re flying blind.
Relationship marketing demands ongoing dialogue with your customers — especially with those who have demonstrated long-term loyalty. Note that complaints can be at least as valuable to your long-term success as praise. Armed with such information, you are able to do less of what aggravates your customers, and more of what pleases them — targeting specific activities to various segments of your market, and sometimes even to markets of one. The most successful companies have long known this intuitively, and acted upon it. But now, with database marketing in place, that process can be managed far more effectively — though it will always be 75 percent art and only 25 percent science.
Providing outrageous, "knock-your-socks-off" product/service delivery to these top-tier, most loyal customers will strengthen your internal service values. Your employees will feel better about themselves, and begin delivering higher levels of service, even beyond top-tier customer groups.

A note of caution: Be careful about basing your acquisition strategy primarily on price concessions. If that’s your definition of "value," it’s likely to become theirs as well. Ironically, in some industries programs designed to target "ideal" customers have, themselves, converted those customers into undiscriminating price-shoppers. An extremely practical tool by which to judge the appropriate investment into so-called ideal customers is to perform defection analysis.
Consider the airlines’ "frequent flyer" programs, aimed at lucrative business travelers. Initial introductions were enormously successful as relationship-builders. But as "me-too" programs proliferated, any competitive advantages in terms of customer loyalty evaporated — leaving only the liability of a lot of free travel vouchers. The lesson to be learned is that price-cutting is a game everyone can play (and probably will, once someone else initiates it).

Loyalty versus Frequency Focus
Loyalty Focus Frequency Focus
Recognizes: Heterogeneity Homogeneity
Employee Contribution Responses to Mailings
Value-Added Transaction-Based
Customer-Focused Competition-Focused
Needs-Based Incentive-Driven
Relationship Focus Payout Focused
Two-Way Dialogue One-Way Communications
One Size Fits One One Size Fits All
Mailing List Bias
Outside-In Focus Inside-Out Focus
Focused Targeting Indiscriminate Targeting
Measures: Share of Customer Response Rate
Share of Requirement RFM
Duration of Relationship Cost per Response
Expense: Revenue for Customer Expense: Revenue for Mailing

Sustainable competitive advantage in wooing customer loyalty demands deeper understanding of what those customers really want — and then responding to their concerns by adding customization, convenience, and solutions relevant to them.

From that beginning, as a natural offshoot, your service delivery system will improve for more and more of your selected customers, present and potential. You will be investing necessarily-limited resources where they will have the most powerful impact on your future profitability — and in proportion to the level of commitment those customers have demonstrated to you. Our experience has been that using the preferred medium within a segment often improves the perceived level of service delivery while decreasing the cost of doing business as a percent of revenue. Your employees and channel partners will experience renewed enthusiasm as they find themselves increasingly able to provide true value, on their customer’s terms. And, you will be well-positioned to segment your universe of potential customers, pursuing like companies to build a growing base of loyal customers.
This strategy, mightily enhanced by the insights database marketing provides, is at the heart of building customer loyalty.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

revisiting: Actionable, needs-based segmentation

Decisions, decisions, decision. Targeting, Segmentation and Grading are three of the more important decisions any company can make. In fact, Targeting, Segmentation and Grading (i.e., the valuation of customers, prospects and the “universe” from which to choose) are the primary building blocks of an effective CRM and CEM (customer experience management) strategy. These actionable steps represent conscious management decisions based upon business intelligence, corporate memory, and the on-going strategy of the business plan. “Being in Business” necessitates making decisions. The single most important set of decisions any business-to-business enterprise can make are those involving selection - of the products and services you will provide, of the customers for whom you will provide them, and of the channels through which you will market them, differentiation, sourcing, profitability, etc. Segmentation is at the heart of this selection process. I originally presented this idea of actionable needs-based segmentation more than10 years ago. I want to reiterate the validity of this approach and present some simple tools with which to put these principles into action, while recognizing the need to incorporate the additional insight available to us today as a result of new channels such as social media and the heightening of social responsibility. This “toolkit” is comparable to open-source code. Constructed theoretically over the last 15 + years by integrated databased sales and marketing masters, this approach recognizes that: a. No firm can be all things to all people b. The value of the firm is equal to the sum of all the customers with whom it does business (and yes, your CFO will accept this!). c. All firms are constrained by resource limitations: people, time, money, etc d. It makes compelling sense to invest your sales, marketing, channel management, and customer service dollars and effort in direct proportion to the expected return on that investment e. Especially in tough economic times, investing in customer relationship management and customer experience management positions a firm for competitive uniqueness as business improves Accordingly, actionable segmentation to promote selectivity and wiser investment decisions is one of the most valuable applications for your marketing database and your CRM/CEM initiatives.

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

Modern Distribution and the systems thinker

Shaping the future role of distribution for AG: Scenario Planning and Simulation Games as business tools.
One of the most important books of the last decade of the 20th century is "The Fifth Discipline by Peter Senge. It delves into "systems thinking," "pattern mastery," and how to create "systems thinkers" and "learning organizations." In "Learning" corporations may have their most powerful and truly their only unique competitive weapon and advantage. Senge and many leaders since have certainly made this argument resonate. In my work, I often use these "patterns" and associated "mental models" to assist clients to diagnose their current situation. Another important contribution of the work at MIT, another tool that we can use to step back and see the whole, is "simulation games." There are two marvelous games, I have seen and use. One of the most entertaining and instructive games available is The Beer Distribution Game. Literally thousands of teams from across multiple industries and the private sector have played, and usually lost, this “production/distribution” game, since it was developed in the 1960’s at MIT. the other is "the fish banks simulation." These games are set up as “laboratory replicas” of a real setting, and the framers have been able to isolate “the disabilities and their causes more sharply than in real organizations.” Learning from these simulations allows us to step-back and see issues and problems as well as to design wholistic solutions.

The major premise of this learning is that “it reveals that the problems originate in basic ways of thinking and interacting, more than in peculiarities of organization structure and policy.”

Stepping back, examining our preconceptions and mental models, and creating a future solution is one of the leadership challenges each of us face. Individuals who make a habit of this are known as “systems thinkers.” Now, while that may sound like some esoteric academic pursuit it really isn’t. Simply put it means stepping back and seeing patterns that are intuitive and easy to grasp. Stepping back and seeing these patterns in our everyday businesses and especially against our strategy for the future can allow us to make decisions to ensure our corporate profitable, longevity and sustainability.

Two of the more familiar patterns are called “The tragedy of the commons” and “shifting-the-burden.”By analogue, the channel, our distribution partners, can be viewed as "the commons."

"The Commons" usually refers to a shared resource. individuals hoping to maximize their own individual gain end up diminishing the benefits for everyone involved: the result of what originally was a great idea can become " a collective nightmare for all."

Two great illustrations of the structural problem are: 1. common grazing land or, 2. the neighborhood swimming hole The tragedy of the commons can be best described as a situation in which it makes sense for each "player" in this "drama" to pursue their own best interests. In the case of the swimming pool, so long as the activity involves only a small number of people relative " to the amount of the commons" (the pool space) available, each individual will continue to enjoy some benefit. If the the number of people grows too large for the pool space, our quality of experience goes down. Those evenings when we drive to the swimming hole and find out that all of our neighbors are there, our quality of experience diminishes to nearly zero. In the simulation game for grazing land, when that "commons" becomes depleted, herds shrink, land no longer can bear the grazing and everyone suffers?

In other words, there are underlying limits. If the players in these games fail to step back and understand the larger system of which their company is only a single player, they lose sight of the end game: "business-as-usual" can easily end up causing everyone to lose.

So my question is:
How well do you think this analogue applies to the challenge of crafting a future distribution and channel model to best serve our customers, our channel partners, our stakeholders? I'd really like your comments.

Monday, August 10, 2009

CRM: Why now? Strategy may dictate it.

“Clarity of purpose, clarity of understanding” – Zen proverb.

As an effective business leader and manager, you work to keep your organization on track by trying to answer…

a. Who are you?

b. Why are you here?

c. Where are you going?[1]

The primary thing in your mind is to “clarify and communicate Identity, Purpose & Long-Range Intention.”[2] My vantage as an advisor & teacher allows me to look at the world from a multi-disciplinarian’s point of view. Educated to be a scholar and teacher, I wound up in business. Thankfully, I discovered Agribusiness and CRM.

Why CRM and Why now?

My friend and chief project manager reminded me that:

“… there is no time like the present to focus on effective and measurable CRM.”

Now, to broaden my background, I spent much of the last 4 years in banking, so I know firsthand the fragility of the global economy and the importance of cultivating loyalty with our core customers: one of the central tenets of Customer Relationship Management. As I was reminded:

“the current economic conditions absolutely necessitate that you never take your customers for granted and that you know with certainty if your marketing and sales investments are really working.”

Chrysalis Marketing knows CRM and we offer a holistic, thoughtful, and measured approach to implementing strategy, to delighting, and to keeping your customers. We have strong opinions on how to keep them delighted, as well as how to find, acquire, and retain other customers who look like your most loyal and profitable customers. We believe we have a proven, albeit methodical, approach: a roadmap to successful Customer Relationship, and Customer Experience, Management. It is an outshoot of our passion as agribusiness professionals, to put forth and share our passion with you.

Passion, for the student of life, is a fascinating emotion. My passion in business is about creating customer-based, customer-focused business models, in the business-to-business world. Customer Relationship Management (CRM) is hard-wired in my DNA. Trained as a critical thinker and recruited into the performance management industry in the mid-80’s, I also have a deep background in Customer Management Centers (usually termed “call centers” – but they can be so much more!) and was a distributor. Now, it often happens that individuals find it difficult to take disparate experiences and build upon them. I’ve been blessed, however. And, “it” all came together for me when I first sold marketing services (research, training, incentives, marketing communications, etc.) into agribusiness, while simultaneously Rapp and Collins offered their first work on database marketing. Those confluence of events coalesced as a business “epiphany”.

This light-bulb that went on helped me realize that data, i.e., simple informational facts, were beginning to be affordable (as the cost of computerized memory & storage plummeted) and that companies could use that data, if they translated it into actionable knowledge, to create a bond with their customers. Thus began databased marketing, followed by what the industry pundits termed “integrated, direct, databased marketing”. Those key trends laid the foundation for Customer Relationship Management and, what we now term, Customer Experience Management.

In most simple terms, CRM is business strategy: a set of decisions that a company needs to cultivate “customer intimacy” as a disciplined, core competency. And it is one that proactively manages the customer lifecycle. CRM uses people, processes, and data, translated into “actionable knowledge” in order to manage these 4 ever-repeating stages of a business’ customer lifecycle and experience management, viz.;

1. Customer acquisition

2. Customer assimilation/nurturing & retention

3. Customer defection and purposeful release

4. Customer “win-back”[3]

Put another way: as business leaders we share certain common challenges as we formalize our strategic direction, viz.:

1. how to build a relevant business model that delivers value

2. how to manage our business in a flat-world, driven in near-real time

3. how to deal effectively in deploying our limited resources: people, time, money, and data

4. how to build loyalty across our “value chain”

Loyalty of the right, core customers forms the basis of well-functioning CRM efforts and the touchstone of our organic growth strategy.

Let me stop for a moment to consider these points in a little more detail. Creating a business model that delivers relevance and value to our targeted customers traditionally ensured that we would succeed. Business Designs, however, grow old and stale. Over the last 15 years, as marketing management grew closer to becoming a scientific discipline, we have learned that customers will leave if, as their needs and ever-evolving definitions of value change, the Business Design fails to provide relevance and value.[4]

The next 2 points, the “flat-world” in Internet-defined time and the limited resources of our companies, should be self-evident, but I think we often overlook the huge implications of both. Issues such as immediacy, transparency, and how we invest our limited resources require deliberate attention to detail – are we sometimes failing to pay close attention enough? Finally, the term “value chain “refers to all those “entities” from product inception, creation, design, etc. to market-coverage.

In sum we can look at the implications for our business strategy. Strategy, per Porter is about “choice; or, more bluntly, per Slywotzky, “selection” is the single most important decision any company can make: selection of things such as:

a. why we are in business

b. who are our targeted customers

c. how will we make money, etc

In today’s financially troubled world, our imperative in agribusiness is to make a decision, to select to use CRM as our governing strategy, allowing for 2 admonitions, viz.:

1. As sellers, we avoid the two most common errors:

a. Wasting time-consuming and price-inflation relationship programs on transaction buyers, or

b. Approaching relationship buyers with transaction-oriented strategies.”[5]

We know that the various functional areas in each of our firms must be aligned better and must cooperate fully, while coordinating all customer-focused activity. As such, our “core leadership Challenge is: coordinating marketing, sales”, product development, operations, service, etc.[6] In practice, those companies that first transform themselves so that this structural and process modification has been done internally. and who then take this same alignment out to the marketplace, when dealing with their channel and end-user communities, have been highly effective and created effective, successful CRM efforts.[7]

So how will this newsletter provide value to you?

As a writer, I am driven by my passion, my experience in business and daily life, and a hope that what I have to say will assist and stimulate my readers.

Our intention for this blog, this ongoing series of attempts to communicate, is to satisfy many levels for our community of participants. Our hope is to:

· present, debate, and synthesize the key business strategies and concepts pertaining to CRM strategy, business design, implementation and practice- inspecting carefully the dynamics across our “value chain”- the producers and growers who are our customers and our channel partners;

· open a new forum in agribusiness, which welcomes dialogue and/or debate concerning the issues of customer definition and selection, sales, marketing & service; channel management, and what we believe is a healthy tension with our channel partners, needed in our distribution-enhanced B2B world;

· offer counsel and guidance

· suggest a “new covenant” across that “value chain”

· suggest how both our metaphorical description of the “game of agribusiness” needs to change , and to suggest just how to “change the game”

· demonstrate a roadmap, constructed under an actionable framework, on how to build a successful Customer Relationship Management (CRM) solution, producing a business model (design) that is customer-based and customer focused

We will inspect the key issues of agribusiness. We intend to provide focus and direction of the key management ideas, concepts, strategies, and issues, which have to be accomplished by, with, and through people, processes, and data transformed into actionable knowledge.

For Chrysalis Marketing, our business is to provide value to you in Agribusiness. Our bailiwick includes CRM strategy development and execution, channel management, sales, and marketing, service and call centers; event management, and customer insight. We look forward to hearing from you over the next years.



[1] Cf., Pg. 27,Executing Your Strategy: how to break it down & get it done, Harvard Press, 2007: story of border guard’s questions to young boy traveling from East to West Germany in the 1960’s.

[2] Ibid, pg. 27: what the authors call “Ideation.”

[3] Cf., Customer Win-back, Jill Griffin & Michael Lowenstein, Jossey-Bass, 2001. In her book, Jill was kind enough to feature the type of customer buying behavior analysis we first proposed in the late ‘90’s while working with Vic Hunter of Hunter Business Group.

[4] Cf., The contributions of Adrian Slywotzky, beginning with Value Migration, are inestimable.

[5] Concurrent Marketing, Frank Cespedes, Harvard Press, 1995.

[6] Ibid., : i.e., the imposition of a “concurrent marketing” framework

[7] Adapted from Cespedes presentation to The Marketing Science Institute 18 months previous.