Monday, November 28, 2011
Thanksgiving reflections: Principled negotiations with no absolutisms
Was Heisst Denken? Thinking.
At Thanksgiving we all are wont to pause and give thanks. Turkey and Packers have, for decades, brought laughter, excitement, and joy along with calories galore to Wisconsin tables. This year, let us tie that thanks to a new thoughtfulness, a thoughtfulness that then extends outward into all that we do and are, both for this present Holiday season and into our everyday lives. What calls for thinking? What is thinking? About what are we to think? And, why might it be more essential to our future than ever in our lifetimes?
Heidegger, in addition to challenging us with this intensely profound question, is justly famous for two oft-quoted statements: “Language is the house of Being” and “Language creates world.” He often uses philology and etymology to search for ways by which to ascertain the meaning behind the meaning, that which is concealed. In honor of our Thanksgiving Day celebrations, let me offer a glimpse at his thinking about “thanks”.
“The Old English, thencan, to think, and thancian, to thank, are closely related; the Old English noun for thought is thanc or thonc – a thought, a grateful thought, and the expression of such a thought; today it survives in the plural thanks.”
Did you pause and take notice of the final words? There is truly a deep-seated connection in our native language, a connection that links thought-thanks-thinking-memory together. “Language creates world.” Can we find the time to hear what the assertion reveals? Does that simple statement mean something to us; or, are we so distracted by our always on, 24/7 whirlwind of activities, and thus prevented from reading deeply? Do we see these words in much the same way we internalize an internal memo via email? Thanksgiving Day. A day of re-remembering; a day when we can gather, and in that gathering recognize that we do have a commonality, an obligation to listen authentically to one another, an obligation to come together and create world, an obligation which must be honored in this present now, if we wish to co-create a sustainable future, inclusive of all, demanding that all might flourish.
Heidegger is asking us to re-remember the power of thought, the power of language. It is not a new, or novel, concept. Take the Gospel of John. The Gospels, in our age of inclusion and cultural diversity, remain one cultural touchstone that many of us still share. Grab your Bible; open to the Gospel according to John. Read the opening verses about creation. Holding in our thoughts the fact that when John wrote, the opening of John is a Gnostic hymn: Language is in the presence of Being [God], and Language is Being: world was made through the power of thought and naming. Heidegger’s assertions about language and its power are based upon John, our cultural “locus classicus” pertaining to the creation of world.
So too each of us can create world, construct that House of Being in which we most want to exist, through Language. We live in a passionate, divisive time. We need passions now, perhaps more than ever. Our nation is in decline; politically and culturally we seem paralyzed by our partisan divide and our several fears.
It is time to set aside our fears. It is time to participate in this new social revolution, embracing the change it portends, shaping the change through our language and openness.
Our governors, city officials, and national politicians have failed in there tasks. Now it is our turn to solve the problems of our present-, and future-, nows. Ken Chenault from AmEx offered this advice: we need principled negotiations with out any absolutism. So as you sit down to dinner this week with family and friends, please take time to give thanks, to think, and to begin the healing process of coming together.
Then, take a new look at Heidegger. Begin your day with a short thought from his work on language and thinking. Holding thought, revealing that which has been concealed and hidden, are two challenges we all face. Together, however, having gathered and listened authentically, we than will be able to move forward together. We still can co-create a world for our children and grandchildren.
“Is thinking a giving of thanks? What do thanks mean here? Or do thanks consist in thinking? What does thinking mean here? Is memory no more than a container for the thoughts of thinking, or does thinking itself reside in memory?”
What are we to do with this? For many of us, it is easy simply to either dismiss, or acknowledge, and then to “walk away” from the thinking. Let us stay in the clearing, out of the darkness of media pundits and talking heads: let us use language to create, to heal, to fabricate a new house of Being for all.
Wednesday, August 3, 2011
Unterwegs zur: Diagnostics, Facilitation, and Coaching for the B2B CRM & CEM Strategists
As I walked in this morning, I saw a large horse fly resting on the sidewalk. Huge, not particularly attractive: it couldn’t possibly fly. When She (sic!) created flying creatures, people asked what God had been thinking to design the horse fly or the bumblebee. After all we know that God has a grand design and all creation fits into the plan according to Her design. In truth, however, God’s design of bumblebees and horse flies has come under question for centuries. As in: what was She thinking? Or, nothing designed that way can fly. Yet, we know that both creatures do fly and do so well. What works so easily for God does not work as well for humans when it comes to successful planning on how to get to there from here.
Getting from here-to-there is always on everybody’s minds; and, getting from here-to- there is always already a clearly visible destination. Truth is, however: often we get lost on the way. [And, no! I really do not just mean driving directions]. I’m thinking more along the lines of the transformation the US now faces as the Tea Party tries to hold the nation hostage and take its citizens back to the 1787-9 period; or, a lot more simple to solve, how to transform a business into a customer-centered, customer-based business.
The challenges are so immense as to risk hyperbole. The missteps made happen so frequently and predictably that there must be a better way.
We no longer can afford missteps in today’s hyper-competitive, always-on, flat world. No, what we need is a way to assure breakthrough performance and to assure creation of a roadmap that outlines our best chance to arrive at the destination, the desired end-state.
And it really is quite simple to effect best-planning and execution of these crucial transformations. The keys are diagnostics, facilitation, and coaching.
Plans, lucid, readable and comprehensible roadmaps are important, nay vital to success: whether it is a “simple” exercise, such as taking your family of 5 to [you fill-in-the-blanks] for a mini-summer vacation, or (more) complex such as planning for your 24 year old daughter’s dream wedding, or compound-complex as in establishing your firm’s new customer centered and customer focused strategy. (Thinking of plans as a type of sentence construction may be a helpful metaphor).
Distractions, unanticipated events, setbacks, life: all these “things” happen and so our best laid plans somehow end up producing horse flies rather than hummingbirds. Problem is our horse flies don’t fly. Our “success” at planning, unfortunately, does not translate into successful implementation and operational effectiveness.
And, so what?! What now? How can your B2B CRM & CEM strategy be implemented successfully, without a hitch? How do we plan for life to happen and keep on the path. As I began to write this paragraph these 2 phrases surfaced: “Seek first to understand.” “Start with the end in mind.” And, yes, both pieces of advice are apropos of this discussion. Do they give a way to find planning and implementation success? I think they do. And, I think they do because they un-conceal what has been hidden or that which may distract.
What is needed is diagnostics, facilitation, and coaching. The process will clearly define 3 critical areas: 1. Where you are starting from: the point of departure or your “Current State”; 2., Where you intend to end up: your destination or “Desired End-State”; and, 3., the stuff that has to be done, accomplished, solved, etc. so that you can, in fact, get from here to there: “the bridging tasks”.
Unterwegs zur…
Monday, July 25, 2011
Laying out the B2B CRM Roadmap , part III
What is needed is a framework for determining how to allocate resources. There are a great many steps involved, yet, in some ways, creating this framework is much like connecting the dots. Below are some types of information that may be required to build an effective allocation model:
• Company strategy and vision
• Target market
• Customer and market reach
• Definition of customer
• Go-to-market mechanism
• Activity based costing (or economic value added) analysis of the marketing, sales, and service processes
• Analysis of current and required customer knowledge, customer economics, and the technologies used to connect with customers
• Map of current market coverage with number of accounts (targeted, actual, and potential) by territory
• Understanding of account segment membership
• An account contact matrix model
• An account valuation/weighted potential model
• A volume/margin/duration model (to manage customer equity)
• Results from qualitative, directional research that includes marketing, sales, service, and the end-user customer (plus channels[s], if applicable)
• Data about customers: e.g., customer cycles (buying, budgeting, forecasting), number of contacts per site, key influencers by site in the complex selling decision, etc.
• Accurate time/responsibility mapping for field sales and service personnel
• The right set of metrics
Although the preceding list looks more like a laundry list than a practical approach, we can, in practice, proceed from the point of accumulating this knowledge to crafting an actionable coverage and resource allocation model for the company
The Building Blocks
The primary building block for moving forward will be an analysis of the current portfolio of your customers. Combining the knowledge acquired from the steps identified above together with the results of an analysis of the economics of sales, customer service, marketing and channel coverage, takes us to the point of crafting a final resource allocation model. One practical tool is to create a customer pyramid which analyzes value. (see familiar Rubik’s cube, illustrates both the architecture of the marketing database and the model for account penetration and cross selling. In other words, it emphasizes that the single biggest win from data-based marketing comes from penetration of existing accounts. The marketing database needs to track individuals by buyer group or functional need at the site level within the enterprise. The x-axis represents the functional areas within your customer’s organization. The y-axis allows you to track the value of the relationship with your customer (from suspect to target to trial buyer to buyer to apostle). The z-axis portrays the locations or street addresses of your customer’s various site locations.
And, while the marketing databases can be used to acquire customers, a much more profitable use for the marketing database comes from account penetration. This is, selling more products to additional buyers and selling additional products and services to all buyers.
In order to have a holistic view of the sales and marketing system, a closed-loop feedback system must exist. It is well represented by the familiar household funnel. We can use it to discuss the flow of data in a direct response, opportunity/lead management environment. The top half of the diagram portrays the flow and accumulation of the information, while the lower half shows the interaction with your sales group and channel partners. We can visually map the transfer of knowledge that can take place in an effective process of managing leads and opportunities.
Metrics is an additional benefit of using this graphic. One set of metrics measures the effectiveness of the communications stream. The second set of metrics measures the field’s effectiveness.
Keep in mind what relationship marketing is not – it is not direct mail nor is it telemarketing. It is the integration of all contact media to effect a measurable response that simultaneously manages the point of contact with the value chain.
The contact matrix, then, is a simplistic, activity-based costing model that incorporates three variables:
1. Account valuation or grading
2. Cost per contact medium
3. Cost of doing business as a percentage of revenue (E:R) by grade level and in total
Several things are worth consideration. Previously, direct marketers have judged success on a responsive rate. But response rate alone is a destructive measure that belies the workings of your marketing system. The preferred, more constructive, and more holistic measure is to examine the effectiveness of sales leverage to generate a return, balanced across all contact media. In other words, the contact matrix allows management a simple framework for managing cost to serve.
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Resource Allocation for the B2B CRM Practitioner
• Increased sales Effectiveness and Efficiency
* Increased Profits
* Increase in customers served and products placed within customer accounts
• Increased Customer/Employee Satisfaction
• Decreased cost-to-serve
The second “secret” is that virtually every organization has limited resources: People, Money, Time.
Optimization of the respective coverage models - sales, customer service, marketing and channels - still has not been exhaustively studied. The models and tools of the eCRM practitioner provide almost a dot-to-dot like template with which to assure coverage optimization and hence optimal use of the firm’s limited resources.
The third “secret” is that our customers represent a portfolio of assets that we must proactively manage in order to maximize shareholder and stakeholder value.
Whether the resource is time, money, or people, the optimal allocation of resources is a critical issue, a critical challenge, for almost every business organization. Since no enterprise has unlimited resources, it is worth investigating how customer relationship marketing models can provide a critical key to unlock the answer to this problem.
In no functional area of business is this resource allocation problem more true than in sales, marketing, and servicing customers and/or prospects. In fact, the search for the optimal allocation of resources in these functional areas is something akin to the search for the Holy Grail.
In business-to-business marketing the characteristics of the target customer group can commonly be depicted visually as a pyramid, with the largest accounts at the top of the pyramid, and moving down through a group of middle accounts trying to grow larger and support the pyramid are "minor" accounts.
The pyramid graphically shows how, in most mature, competitive industries, the sales function (together with service and product marketing) is faced with:
• Price and margin pressure at the top of the pyramid, where the size of the targeted accounts is the largest
• Margin (cost-to-serve) pressures at the bottom of the pyramid, where the largest number of accounts exist
• An eventual overabundance of competition – once all your competitors realize where you are making your money - in the middle, where the most profit is initially available
• A shrinking middle layer
If, as has been suggested for the last 15 plus years, we elevate Customer Relationship Management, as core strategy, and Sales to a strategic boardroom issue, we can create the greatest synergy by applying the models of customer relationship marketing, customer insight, and knowledge management to the problem of resource allocation.
One Observation
In addition to the five key inevitable outcomes that result from a well-executed customer relationship marketing competence, other implicit problems are remedied:
• Increased sales
• Increased service levels
• Increased customer and employee satisfaction
• Increased customer and employee retention
• Decreased cost to serve
• Faster product introduction, i.e., speed to market
• More controlled management of product migration by targeted segment
• Decreased cost of doing business as a percentage of sales, i.e., sales expense to revenue ratio (E:R)
The Thesis
The planning tools, operational models, feedback loops, and performance metrics of relationship marketing
are templates that create optimal resource allocation and coverage models. What we have created and replicated across multiple firms in the B2B realm is a roadmap for optimizing the allocation of resources, together with the attendant analysis and implementation.
Friday, October 8, 2010
Metaphors to sell by
Monday, May 17, 2010
A 2010 Loyalty CRM Strategy Roadmap, prt 2
A Strategist’s Business Issues
A strategy can only be executed with focus and choice. It must operate with , what Rich Horwath in Deep-Dive calls, “the discipline to intelligently allocate … resources.” Whether the resource is time, money, or people, the optimal allocation of resources is a critical issue, a critical challenge, for almost every business organization that wants to execute its strategy successfully. Since no enterprise has unlimited resources, it is worth investigating how customer relationship marketing models can provide a critical key to unlock the answer to this problem.
In no functional area of business is this resource allocation problem more true than in sales, marketing, and servicing customers and/or prospects – a market-coverage model, if you will. In fact, the search for the optimal allocation of resources in these functional areas is something akin to the search for the Holy Grail.
In business-to-business marketing (B2B) the characteristics of the target customer group can commonly be depicted visually as the familiar pyramid. Largest accounts on top, smallest on the bottom. The shared, common problem of a target universe, the pyramid graphically shows how, in most mature, competitive industries, the sales function (together with service and product marketing) is faced with:
· Price and margin pressure at the top of the pyramid, where the size of the targeted accounts is the largest
· Margin (cost-to-serve) pressures at the bottom of the pyramid, where the largest number of accounts exist
· An eventual overabundance of competition – once all your competitors realize where you are making your money - in the middle, where the most profit is initially available
· A shrinking middle layer
More than a decade ago Adrian Slywotzky suggested in an article that we elevate sales to a strategic boardroom issue. There never has been a more critical time for many businesses to recommit to elevate Loyalty and CRM to the boardroom level.
I do not presuppose a cookie-cutter approach. But, simplistically, I do believe that building a strategic roadmap for CRM in 2010 should be much like the childhood dot-to-dot challenges, which captivated our imaginations for hours. Especially if we guide our thoughts with the words of philosopher, Jacques Derrida, namely “that the answer is always already there.” In other words, through analysis, diagnosis, business intelligence, customer insight, we can uncover the “dots” that we need to connect in order to drive our Loyalty CRM Strategy towards success. Loyalty CRM: doing business with the right core customer. The roadmap requires discipline, focus, choice, and selectivity. Customer insight, business intelligence, process optimization, communications, and training are the primary ingredients the relationship marketing executive adds to the traditional 5 Forces analysis. Judicious use of these tools together with our marketing imaginations will allow us to uncover the roadmap for our particular company and target universe.
This approach requires cooperation and coordination across the entire company and your “value chain”. As a Loyalty focused CRM strategist you can create great synergy and operational effectiveness to your Loyalty CRM Strategy by applying the models of customer relationship marketing and knowledge management together with a modified activity-based look at resource allocation – your customers as a portfolio to be managed.
The Thesis for identifying the 2010 Loyalty CRM Strategist’s Roadmap
The planning tools, operational models, feedback loops, and performance metrics of relationship marketing are templates that create optimal resource allocation and coverage models. What follows is a guideline for optimizing the allocation of resources, together with the attendant analysis and implementation.
Why do we need a roadmap?
In order to “keep our eye on the ball”, in order to maintain focus on the desired end-state of our strategy, is the simple answer. The 3 primary results executives should expect from a well executed, loyalty-focused CRM Strategy are: Increased sales Effectiveness and Efficiency; Increased Customer/Employee Satisfaction; Decreased cost-to-serve
In addition to the three key very desirable outcomes that result from a well-executed customer relationship marketing competence, other implicit problems can be remedied:
· Increased sales, both volume, margin, and breadth of offerings
· Increased service levels
· Increased customer and employee knowledge sharing
· Increased customer and employee retention
· Customizable coverage
· Faster product introduction, i.e., speed to market
· More controlled management of product migration by targeted segment
· Decreased cost of doing business as a percentage of sales, i.e., sales expense to revenue ratio (E:R)
Customers as “a portfolio of assets”
We live and work in a time in which each of us faces allocation constraints pertaining to use of money, time, and people. Furthermore, the competitive arena we operate in is wholly unlike that of just a few years ago. We have a rare opportunity in today’s struggling economy if we are disciplined in our choices, focus, and resource investment/deployment.
Consider this quandary: If you have limited resources, where do you invest them, and how, in order to maximize your return? Professor Len Schlesinger – who brought “us” the Service-Profit Chain – used to lecture using a 3 X 3 matrix:
Across the top: LOYAL SWITCHER COMPETITIVE
Down the left side: LARGE MEDIUM SMALL
Using this simple framework, that he called “the Marketing Optimization Model”, Professor Schlesinger would challenge his audience and students to solve the problem all strategists face, the resource investment and allocation dilemma. While a 9-box matrix perhaps overly simplifies the coverage and investment challenge, it gets the CRM strategist thinking in the right general areas.
Our customers represent a portfolio of assets that we must proactively manage in order to maximize shareholder and stakeholder value. A complementary truth is that virtually every organization has limited resources. So it is vitally important to invest those limited resource in direct proportion to the return we expect to receive from our investment in our primary assets - our customers.
The marketer’s Holy Grail is to get the right message, product, and/or service to the right person, at the right time, in the format that customers have indicated they prefer. In fact, this is the primary goal of an optimal allocation model.
An optimal coverage model would also:
· Support a retention – and loyalty-focused, customer-based business design
· Make effective use of the organization’s limited resources
· Make investment decisions based on reciprocal commitment or mutual interdependence of your Ideal, Best customer and channel partners
· Establish integration and synergy across the three functional areas responsible for servicing the customers: i.e., product marketing, sales, and customer service.
Stepping Back: there are two reasons that customer relationship Marketing is so powerful when implemented properly. First, the firm focuses on acquiring the Ideal, best customer, and, second, the company manages its customers as a portfolio of assets – investing its limited resources proportionately to the level of commitment that customers and prospects make to the organization.
My contention is that there is a fairly well-defined path the enterprise can take when analyzing and assessing its allocation challenges. This path is mapped out through the use of the tools, templates, and planning by the insightful, analytical, data-based, relationship marketer.
Resource allocation must also bring to bear the relationship marketer’s theories about managing the point of contact, managing the customer across their lifecycle of interactions with the company, managing the value of the customer portfolio, and managing knowledge across the company and across the value chain. Fred Reichheld called it “the customer corridor”: it is really mapping the touch-points between your firm, your target universe and customers, as well as your value chain members. In today’s 24/7, always-on, flat-world seemingly driven by social media, just mapping these touch points and then aligning your company for total cooperation and coordination across the value chain is an immense undertaking. Creating the graphic, however, will serve as a powerful icon inside your firm and will illuminate the challenge of resource allocation relative to your customers’ lifecycle relationship with your firm.
Specifically, there is a spectrum, or “continuum of relevant customer contact activities,” that needs to be mapped to create an optimal and effective resource allocation model.
The first step many organizations will need to undertake is to conduct an audit of their marketing, sales, and customer service activities so as to surface the key interdependencies between them, as well as with site logistics. Think of it as “the programming” phase of dealing with an architect. The Master Builder will want to know how you want to live and function in the new space. The audit seeks to:
· Make visible and apparent where integration between the functional areas is necessary
· Make apparent where non-discretionary accountability must reside
· Revisit the current account selection process
· Revisit key account management practices
· Objectively verify whether an account is relationship – or transaction-oriented
· Assess the skills, training, and behavioral components of the relevant customer contact people in each of the functional areas
· Assess degree of cooperative, cross-functional teamwork along with supporting account planning, communications, and contact management tools
The Determinants
What is needed is a framework for determining how to allocate resources. There are a great many steps involved, yet, in some ways, creating this framework is much like connecting the dots.
A 2010 Strategy Roadmap for CRM, prt. 1
2010 Strategy Roadmap for CRM, part 1.
Strategy is choice. Choice tied directly to Mission, Vision, Values, and Purpose. Choice, Selection, Focus and Differentiation are critical components to any successful strategy.
Customer Relationship Management (CRM), is a strategy based on customer focus, on customer knowledge, and on delighting the customer. CRM is real-time, actionable, customer knowledge management. The best CRM approaches are holistic, involving all facets of your business and demonstrating accountability for results. CRM becomes a guiding philosophy and framework for doing business and includes:
• differentiating and optimizing the customer experience
• building customer knowledge to provide value to both the customer and your business
• taking a portfolio management approach to customers –investing in direct proportion to the expected return from each customer, while realizing that not every customer is worth keeping!
• delivering “value “ as defined by the customer - at each point in the customer’s lifecycle and with all of your customer contacts
The single most important set of decisions any business-to-business enterprise can make are those involving selection - of the products and services you will provide, of the customers for whom you will provide them, and of the channels through which you will market them, of the strategy to differentiate your offerings from your competitors.
Sadly, “something like 90% of companies fail to execute strategies effectively.” Often, the failure to realize a strategy success results from taking your eye off the ball. (In other words, something came up and we paid more attention to that blip than to the strategy). Successful strategy execution will/should allow your business to create a sustainable competitive advantage, to optimize its market-coverage models, to optimize its customer portfolio, to anticipate the shifting nature of value, and to realize loyal customers.
One primary constraint to successful execution of your strategy is that virtually every organization has limited resources: time, people, and resources. Choice, focus, and selection are critical. With today’s business intelligence tools, your firm can easily achieve Optimization of the marketplace coverage models - sales, customer service, marketing and channels. The models and tools of the eCRM practitioner provide almost a dot-to-dot like template with which to assure coverage optimization and hence optimal use of the firm’s limited resources.
A second realization we must still embrace is that no company can be all things to all people. Your customers represent a portfolio of assets that must be proactively managed in order to maximize shareholder and stakeholder value. As strategists we believe that our best customer investment and market strategy would be to invest our limited resources in direct proportion to the expected return on investment
Again, choice, selection, focus, and purpose must serve as constant monitors. While CRM “implementations” still fail – at disappointing level - to achieve what executives expect, It’s no longer a secret, the evidence is compelling and is well documented, both at the academic level and in practice. A strategy of Enterprise-wide Customer Relationship Management – when successfully implemented , whether in the clouds or on-premise- can achieve impressive results.
The most easily measurable results include:
· Increased sales Effectiveness and Efficiency
· Increased Customer/Employee Satisfaction
· Decreased cost-to-serve
In fact, there are 8 benefits. The EIGHT BENEFITS of successful CRM implementations are well documented. With a well-executed strategic CRM program, you can experience and measure:
1. Increased sales
2. Increased profitability
3. Greater product penetration
4. Growth in customer satisfaction and loyalty
5. Increased employee satisfaction
6. Decreased cost-to-serve
7. Increased retention of the existing customer base during times of economic uncertainty.
8. Increased likelihood of new customer acquisition
These maxims are independent of the enabling technology. Successful strategy implementation has more to do with aligning people, processes, and information (yes, data) to the mission/vision/values/ & purpose of the business, to the strategy, than with what software package or cloud-computing platform chosen.
Wednesday, December 30, 2009
thought starter #1: define your customers & measure the value of your marketing database
Thought-starter #1: define your customers & measure the value of your marketing database
One issue organizations often struggle with is “how to measure the value of investments made in its marketing database”. Let’s see if we can build a simple, yet practical, evaluation framework for the marketing database in your company. This approach I believe focuses more on process, information management and outcomes, and this approach is more actionable than traditional ROI measures
a. external service values: i.e., what are the 3,4, or 5 primary reasons customers buy
b. why we lose customers (defection analysis)
c. operational database performance
d. social interaction and customer insight
Today we have richer information: for many of us an overwhelming richness of data & information. Our data mining tools are incredibly sophisticated. Overlay upon overlay of data can give us greater insight than ever before. In general this approach is given the umbrella title of “business intelligence”.
Easier said than done? Not really. You can gather this information initially through investigative research, and then subsequently maintain it through the ongoing contact your customer management center has with your customers, prospects and defectors, using phone, email, and social media. You can then interpret this marketing data to target, to segment and to grade your customers, sharing the data synthesis both inside your organization and with your channel partners to ensure you’re making needed improvements.
In order to add the greatest power to these efforts, you first must define your customer. Yes, define a customer, your customer! The definition of customer is the touchstone upon which all else rests. Without the definition, none of the other steps can take place, and none of this theory can touch ground and add value to your operations and its success.
[1] Grading does not refer to assigning customers “grades” as our teachers did; rather grading is a valuation process, which allows you to optimize your market coverage approach and to manage the limited resources your firm has in direct proportion to the expected returns on that investment. At its center, this approach looks at customer, prospects, & defectors as the portfolio of assets that must be managed proactively.
[2] Essentially the same holds true for partner management initiatives as well.
Monday, November 23, 2009
Words that work: inside the halls of your business
Our direct experience has shown that, in certain agribusiness companies, our workers are feeling the strain of the public debate over food. Has it hit your place yet?
We train our sales people about features and benefits, about how to overcome objections, and about how to close the sale. We guide and train these people but what do we do for the rest of our staffs? And even for our sales people, maybe we haven’t adequately prepared them as well as we could have on talking points and their behaviors. What are you doing to help them deal with emotions and to help them regain their personal confidence through “words that work”?
The words we choose certainly make a definite difference in our relationships with spouses, children, and co-workers. In our business lives, our choice of words can make or break a sales situation, cause a customer service moment to turn ugly, or strike a chord that conveys instant understanding. In fact, our words, in part, define our customers’ experience. Agribusiness companies have employees who take the brunt of the sometimes sensationalized debate home with them. It’s our job to seize upon this time as one of additional education and communication to relieve their stress and to help them use words that work when confronted.
The business model of agribusiness is self-contained, highly complex, and had been virtually hidden from public view until the last 10 to 15 years. The recent increase in public awareness, if graphed, would be up and to the right at a steep angle! How much clarity is there really for the public about agribusiness, farming, sustainability, and feeding and clothing the world? Agriculture cannot withstand a repeat performance of what we are witnessing in the public debate over Health Care Reform.
This is a very public example of what agribusiness is in for in the coming months and years. We’re living through a confused, and angry public debate over our nation’s true and real need for Health Care reform. After months of shouting, influence-led proselytizing, and raucous Town Hall meetings, where are we?
The next great public conversation will be about carbon emissions, global warming, and sustainability. This far-reaching, complex, and already highly fractionalized, conversation will include among its topics “cap and trade” versus “cap and tax”, agribusiness, emissions, the industrial food system, farming, and almost everything and everything related. The conversation, if we allow media to dictate it could become even more sensationalized than the one on Health Care Reform. The message gaining strength and credence, and the doubtless ongoing message will be: how we as “the people” must change past practices to create a sustainable future. Let’s keep that message constructive, educational and balanced.
This is a time to unite. Each of us across the value chain, from grower or producer to seedsman to corporate executive, needs to help shape the language of this conversation. For some of us, we need to start inside our very own businesses.
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
words that work: the wisdom of calling it "a fight"
I was glancing over blog headlines today, when my eye was caught by the headline " A Food Fight."
Like so many others, there are days when I turn off my computer disgusted by the factual mistakes and blatant lies told in the press about agriculture. Growers and producers are misunderstood. Agribusiness is much more complex than almost everyone understands. Agribusiness feeds and clothes the world. American farmers have a proud history of stewardship and sustainability. To date, however, much of the public debate has done more to confuse the general audience with polarizing language and war-like tactics - tactics clearly intended to strike terror into the hearts of the intended audience.
Therefore, I certainly applaud how the industry has been drawn together to reverse public opinion and to correct the facts about farmers, farming, and the "Food industry." What causes me concern, however, is the choice of metaphor.
The blog, which appears on AgWired, starts off:
" A FOOD FIGHT got underway today with dairy farmers and beef producers joining forces to fling facts in the face of food foes."
I have to ask if there isn't another "metaphor to live by" other than the "argument is war" metaphor, which underlies the author's opening lines. Cindy, the author, goes on to say that the purpose and main message from this food fight "is to Give Thanks for food and farmers."
I get her message. Yet the words "fight" and "give thanks for" are oddly juxtaposed.
Those of us involved in agribusiness, whether we are ranchers, producers, growers, farmers, dealers, seedsmen, equipment manufacturers, or marketing consultants, should reflect upon the power of words, ideally before they escape our lips, pens, or keyboards. We don't need a repetition of what has happened in the public debate over health care reform.
We do face a communications "opportunity", or "challenge" when it comes to the subject of food and of creating a sustainable world for future generations. A key to the success of our sustainability efforts will be our ability to come together, despite not being fully comfortable with doing so, and to collaboratively and creatively build a future. I am merely asking us to think about the metaphors we choose to help guide us to that future.
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Alice through the looking glass: words that work or not?
The last few pieces I've posted have dealt with finding "words that work". There can be no more important time to make sure you are using words that work than when speaking to a customer or prospect. Here's an interesting example of such an exchange: between "the customer" and "the company". A passage from Lewis Carroll's Alice Through the Looking-Glass serves as the example.
'Humpty-Dumpty said: "There's glory for you."
"I don't know what you mean by 'glory'," Alice said.
Humpty-Dumpty smiled contemptuously. "Of course you don't till I tell you. I meant, 'There's a nice knock-down argument for you!'"
But 'glory' doesn't mean 'a nice knock-down argument'," Alice objected.
"When I use a word," Humpty-Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, "it means just what I choose it to mean, neither more nor less."
"The question is," said Alice, "whether you can make words mean so many different things."
"The question is," said Humpty Dumpty, "which is to be Master - that's all."
Perhaps the example is a stretch, but each of us can remember an encounter similar I am sure.
Remember: It is not what you say that matters; it is what they hear. More importantly, if they have no idea what you mean by what you say, you can rest assured that what you hear will create a disconnect rather than a deeper connection with your customer.
Sunday, November 1, 2009
The Integrated model - the essence of best practices CRM
The Integrated Model is a Gold Mine: it’s the essence of successful CRM.
In business-to-business marketing, the integrated direct marketing model is a gold mine for the marketing group that wants to build sustainable relationships with the right customers. The Integrated Direct model is the foundation of best practices Customer Relationship Management and Customer Experience Management. The economics of the Integrated Direct model come from two primary facts:
1. Marketers have come to realize that they cannot afford to invest in all customers and prospects equally. In fact, acquisition efforts should be segregated out from cultivation, retention, and “win-back” efforts. Integrated Direct Marketing – that is the integration of your “market coverage efforts (sales, marketing and service) - allows us to do that. This delivers the promise of CRM.
2. More expensive contact types, such as face-to-face or special events, can be leveraged with tremendous effectiveness by lower contact types, such as the Internet, social media, E-mail, print, snail-mail, and phone.
Here’s what the integrated direct marketing process can do for you:
1. Reduce the expense to revenue ratio by at least 15%
2. Increase the number and frequency of value-based contacts to the right prospect or customer
3. Increase the perceived service level at the point of contact
4. Increase product penetration
5. Increase customer loyalty
Additionally, in support of particular product lines, Integrated Direct Marketing ensures:
1. Faster Introduction
2. Higher amplitude of sales
3. Segmented and sustained market position
4. More control when migrating customers to newer models, products and services.
Quoting Bob Stone, long the venerable guru of American direct marketing, a definition of direct marketing must include three phrases: “interactive system,” “using one or more contact media,” and as must all direct marketing “effect a measurable response or transaction.”
Integrated Direct Marketing is not direct mail; it is not telemarketing; it is not transaction focused. The integrated direct marketing model is data-based and loyalty focused. Integrated Direct Marketing is highly targeted marketing that uses an integrated, organized, planned system of contacts by which we make offers to individuals using a variety of media. This system of building sustainable loyalty with our customers and prospects creates an on-going civil dialogue. It is accomplished by integrating communication across all contact media - print, the Internet, E-mail, mail, phone, field events and face-to-face visits from the field force. It’s defining characteristic is the delivery of relevant value. The value is defined for us by our customers and prospects. It provides for the delivery of relevant value-based information at the right time, in the desired delivery system, to the right individual that ensures interdependent relationships built over time.
This “Market Coverage” model makes use of the marketing database as the repository of corporate memory, storing the results of all interactions with customers and prospects.
In addition to simple facts such as demographics and product usage, today’s sophisticated marketers are building database systems that capture the complexity of buyers’ needs and purchasing behavior along with relevant complaint and/or satisfaction issues. The information then is available for product design groups, marketing, sales, research and other corporate functions. The database becomes the springboard for the organization’s need to be responsive, flexible, and dedicated to learning. Through the technology of our database, we are able to store response data by individual contact within an account. Moreover, we are able to measure our effectiveness relative to cost and to results. The measurability tracks profits, investments, expenses, account penetration (or, “share of wallet”), problems, issues, complaints and satisfaction.
Integrated Direct Marketing is a systematic method of getting close to our customers. Using this tool we can integrate our channel contacts and media efforts through a common database, which is focused on our target universe. Through testing we can validate results and expand our program and processes with great certainty.
The marketing database is mind of the IDM organization. It is serviced by a proactive outbound call center (or telemarketing unit), which becomes both a listening post to customers and the dealer channel as well as a way to leverage the field organization in building relationships and selling products. In the Integrated model the marketing database is shared with the field organization, your channel partners, and all internal departments.
The essence of a successful Integrated process is the ability to capture, centrally, information about our customers and prospects at all points of contact – and then to transform that information in actionable knowledge that is shared across and between those functional areas inside your firm that touch the customer or your channel partners. The key to success then is how well the marketer can segment within a given target audience. It is critical in the B2B arena to segment on similar sets of unfulfilled needs and purchasing behavior. This allows us to understand our customers’ need and how they buy and then to market our products and services to these identified niches.
Once the segments have been identified (keeping in mind that the entire target universe may emerge as one large segment), the next step to take is to grade accounts within segments to ensure that the investment made is the least amount of money to strengthen the relationship with the particular account.
The grading model is a valuation model. In the Business-to-Business world, the grading model no longer should be the simplistic A-B-C model. Instead, it should allow enough granularity to understand the profitability and penetration potential of each cohort or segment. I suggest 5 grades, although in certain cases, I believe 7 to be the optimal number of grades.
Grading (or, “valuation”) is the economic modeling of the Integrated Direct effort based upon an investment decision, which takes into, account the historical (actual) revenue and potential revenue from a particular segment of accounts. In other words, grading serves the marketer as an economic and analytical tool, which requires that we invest in the major segments we have created proportional to their economic history and potential.
Integrated direct marketing works both as a stealth defensive weapon, as well as a highly leverageable marketing tool. The competitive advantage it affords the skilled executioner is proprietary and affords increasing , not decreasing, economic returns. The fundamental concepts we use in loyalty-focused customer relationship management include:
1. Market to individuals … not to corporations
2. Address the unique set of needs of that buyer group (or application)
3. Individuals are clustered (i.e., segmented) around common sets of needs which define a market niche
4. All contacts with an individual, whether a customer or a prospect, must be of value as defined by them
5. The technology we use is transparent
6. Planning is critical
7. Testing is mandatory
8. Integration is the process used to ensure that the higher cost contacts are leveraged
9. Properly executed the integrated model creates a continuous improvement process that profitably drives business strategy by creating a sustainable atmosphere of cooperation and coordination across, and between, your company’s various functional areas.
10. The investment made is proportional to the level of commitment to us, to the expected return from this customer.
Sunday, October 25, 2009
it's what people hear
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
The Story of Babel.
All too often we, myself included, fail to realize the power of language in our daily personal interactions. Seemingly, if we stop to think about it at all, we tend to reserve a different style for certain situations versus others. The motives are varied: perhaps we believe that certain occasions, settings, circumstances require more conscious, formal and deliberate language, while others don’t need the precision or effort or . True enough I suppose.
Yet if you stop to listen to conversations, even our own, often words no longer mean what they once did: denotations, connotations, and the satellite of associated images no longer are as rich nor as nuanced. The end-game for casual substitution of one word for another with completely different sense would be a re-enactment of the myth of Babel.
With the fall of Babel, god left confusion: confusion that carries over in our marketing, sales and service language and CRM efforts. In the words of Willis Barnstone , “…God dispersed the word, gave us tongues and the solitude of difference, and also the impossible but pleasurable duty to repair our separation.” Translation necessarily must be a key component of our relationships and conversations. Translation is an important tool with which we can rebuild a new tower of Babel. Barnstone believes “it is an impossible task”; and, I believe it is one that clearly haunts our customer relationship efforts.
The challenge is when one word is substituted for another or mistranslated in the mind of either the speaker or listener. The slippery slope here would results with words in casual conversation having lost their precision; they no longer would retain the power of their meaning; and, eventually one word could be substituted for any other with impunity. The crime of being careless and imprecise eventually could bring about the demise of language. In all words would become the same.
Communication, as Lakoff & Johnson point out[1], “is based upon the same conceptual system that we use in thinking and acting.” When trying to build a loyalty relationship with your targeted and best, core customers, what metaphors does your organization use in its conversations with others: customer, business partners, suppliers, employees, investors, etc.? Two metaphorically structured concepts to think about are:
ARGUMENT IS WAR (think about that next time your group talks about its “campaign”).
Or,
THEORIES (AND ARGUMENTS) ARE BUILDINGS
Such mental frameworks do color our efforts to build customer relationship management and loyalty. There are a myriad of other examples about how language shapes our reality and relationship, such as: “orientational metaphors” such the special concepts “virtue is up; depravity is down” or Rational is up; Emotional is down”
In truth however, language is one of our most powerful tool in building relationships. We live according to the metaphors of our daily exchanges. The simple fact is “our ordinary conceptual system, in terms of which we both think and act, is fundamentally metaphorical in nature.”[2] Are we overlooking the power and value of crafting consciously the metaphors that shape our attitudes, demeanor and behavior? Our assumption is that looking at these questions squarely in the face might do more for our relationship and loyalty efforts than we previously have given credit.